Tuesday, July 14, 2015
The 50 Greatest Dodger Games of All Time
J. P. Hoornstra
There was a knock on
our door last fall, just after we had settled in. It is a long and exhausting
journey to Fort Myers from Wellington , and it takes me some to adjust. I
opened the door to my good friend Mike Richey. He handed me a baseball. It had
been signed by Carl Erskine. Mike hails from Pendleton, Indiana, which is a
stone’s throw from Anderson .
Erskine resides in Anderson .
Erskine grew up in
Anderson, attended high school, and still lives there. He will be 89 in
December. Erskine played for the Dodgers, first in Brooklyn, then in Los Angeles . He was
fortunate to play for the Dodgers at a time when they established themselves as
the best team in baseball. They won the World Series in 1955, the first time in
franchise history.
He played for the
Dodgers from 1948 to 1959, and retired because of injury. He entered the
business world, and later became president of the Star Bank of Anderson . His philanthropic work in the state
of Indiana is
extensive. He donated land to the Anderson
Community School
System. The Erskine
Elementary School was built
on the site.
The exploits of the
Dodgers from that era are well recorded in Roger Kahn’s great book, “The Boys
of Summer”. Another book on Dodger baseball has recently hit the shelves: “The
Fifty Greatest Dodgers Games”. It was written by J. P. Hoornstra who is the
ultimate authority on Dodger baseball. He reports on the team for the Los
Angeles News Group. I am certain that he bleeds “Dodger Blue”.
For many years,
beginning in the early 50s, I was a New
York Yankee fan. It was not difficult because they
were in the hunt every year. They had the most glamorous players, and they
were, in fact, the closest franchise to the main cities in Canada . My
visit to Yankee Stadium in 1954 to see the Yankees and the Cleveland Indians sealed the deal for me.
The fifty chapters in
the book tell the tales of the fifty games that Hoornstra has selected. In the
countdown from 50, chapter 11 refers to Manager Charlie Dressen’s time with
Erskine. “Oisk” was the name attached to Erskine. It is a derivative of his
last name in “Brooklynese”. In 1952, Oisk had just pitched the fifth game of
the World Series, all eleven innings. After the game, he fielded questions from
the media, while shaving. He had a date that evening. It was his fifth wedding
anniversary.
The Dodgers jumped
out to a 4-0 lead in that game on an RBI single from Andy Pafko, a sacrifice
fly from Pee Wee Reese, and a two run homer off the bat of Duke Snider. The
Yankees came storming back and took the lead. Erskine was sure that he was
going to get the hook at that stage; however, in his trip to the mound, Dressen
asked Erskine what his plans were for that evening. He retired the next
nineteen Yankee batters, with none reaching first base. He was supported by
great fielding, particularly by Pafko and Carl Furillo. Yankee manager Casey
Stengel remarked, “I never saw two better catches anywhere”. Unfortunately, the
Dodgers lost the next two games, and the Series.
The chapters are not
in any chronological order. Each one is a fine read all on its own. Little
fragments of baseball history.
As is the case with
these reviews, this book will be on the shelves of the Wellington Library in a week. A must read for
any Dodger fan.
James Hurst
July 14, 2015